%402x.svg)
Is your website acting like it's on a first date with your leads, only to leave them hanging afterward? You’re not alone. Many businesses struggle with converting website traffic into leads, and it often boils down to a few common issues that are easy to fix once you know where to look. From slow loading times to poor navigation, these mistakes can be the silent killers of your lead-generation efforts.
Let’s walk through the issues and solutions to help your website stop ghosting your leads and start turning them into loyal customers.
1. Bad Navigation Is Like a Bad First Date
You’ve probably been there: you visit a website, and within a few seconds, you’re lost. You can’t find what you’re looking for and end up abandoning the page. Poor navigation doesn’t just frustrate visitors—it costs you conversions. If your visitors can’t quickly find the information they need, they’ll leave. In fact, 94% of users cite poor website navigation as the primary reason they abandon a site.
Fix It:You have to make sure your website’s structure is intuitive. Keep navigation simple and easy to understand with clear categories, a search bar if you have a lot of content, and quick links to key pages. And remember—less is more. Too many options can overwhelm visitors. Creating main pages and subpages with dropdowns is a great way to allow more navigation items without congesting the space. Your header should never take up more than 5-10% of the screen. Making sure it scales responsively is very important—see #3!
2. Is Your Website Taking Too Long to Load?
Site speed is one of the most critical factors for user experience. Slow loading times can kill conversions and cause frustration. Studies show that 53% of mobile users will abandon a site if it takes longer than 3 seconds to load. If your website is slow, your leads are literally running away before they even get a chance to see what you have to offer.
Fix It:One of the biggest killers of site speed is large images and videos. Take the time to optimize images, use faster web hosting, and eliminate unnecessary plugins or add-ons that need to load on the page. Tools like Google PageSpeed Insights can give you a detailed breakdown of what’s slowing your site down and how to fix it. Converting images to WebP format can be a great way to minimize load times. Make sure animations on your page load quickly enough during scroll, and try to limit GIF files by converting them to Lottie files, which are often 3000x smaller in file size.
3. Mobile Responsiveness: Is Your Website Designed for All Devices?
Did you know that over 60% of internet traffic comes from mobile devices? If your website isn’t responsive, meaning it doesn’t adjust to different screen sizes, you’re alienating a huge chunk of your audience. A poor mobile experience can lead to high bounce rates and low conversion rates. If you’re doing any type of lead generation, especially through social media, consider where your visitors are coming from. Does your navigation bar show appropriately on a cell phone? Are forms the right width for easy entry?
I had a client who wanted to start doing lead generation because they weren’t getting the pull-through they wanted. They had structure and calls to action, but when I viewed their form on mobile, the input boxes were so small I could barely select the name section, let alone read what I was typing. After making this one small change, his small business saw a 340% increase in form submissions.
Fix It:Make sure your website looks and functions great on all screen sizes—desktop, tablet, and mobile. Most modern website builders are mobile-responsive by default, but always double-check by testing your site on various devices, especially when adding new sections and forms. WordPress users, check twice, and maybe even on another user’s phone or browser as well to ensure responsiveness. Every site we build at Black Cloud Designs is mobile-responsive, giving the user a similar view and experience, regardless of the viewing device.
4. CTAs That Aren’t Taking Action
Your Calls to Action (CTAs) are like the handshake at the end of a great conversation—they should be clear, compelling, and actionable. If your CTAs are hidden or too vague, your leads won’t know what to do next.
You should always want a Call to Action above the fold. Two things:
- What is "the fold"? The fold is the imaginary line you draw on a webpage. When you land on a page, everything you see before you scroll is above the fold.
- Why is that important? As mentioned above, many users may never scroll on your site, and the important elements should always be visible on the first screen they see—above the fold. A well-placed, actionable CTA can increase conversion rates by up to 30%.
If you’re thinking, “But I have my phone number above the fold, and the contact link there too—they know how to contact me,” you may be right about where they are, but they don’t want to. You need to tell them what to do. If you want them to contact you, ask them, “Let’s talk!” If you have a limited-time offer, add a timer to your CTA, so they know time is running out, like, “Click Now, Only 00:00 remaining to Claim Your ___.”
Fix It: Place CTAs prominently on your website—preferably above the fold—and use action-oriented text like "Get a Free Quote," "Schedule Your Consultation," or "Download Our Guide." And remember, CTAs should be easy to spot and clearly tell users what to do next, in a branded color.
5. Are You Providing Value, or Just Asking for the Sale?
Is your website all sales pitches, or does it offer something of value? Giving your visitors useful content that helps them make decisions is an excellent way to build trust and increase the chances of conversion. If your site is all about pushing products without educating your visitors, they’re less likely to engage.
Fix It: Add value to your visitors’ experience by offering educational content. Blog posts, downloadable guides, videos, and free resources are great ways to build trust and establish yourself as an expert. The more you teach, the more your visitors will want to stay.
6. Lead Follow-Up Efficiency: The Secret Stuff to Conversion
You’ve captured a lead—now what? If your website has generated leads but your team isn’t following up in a timely or efficient manner, those leads are going to get cold fast. Whether it’s missed phone calls, delayed emails, or poor handling of inbound inquiries, follow-up is often where most businesses lose their leads.
I once worked with a service-based client who wanted to run lead generation campaigns, but despite a healthy budget for ads, they insisted their staff would manually handle the follow-up. The problem? Staff weren’t trained for timely follow-up and had no system for managing leads. The result? Low conversion rates and a campaign that fizzled out after just two months. Lead generation isn’t an overnight success—it takes time, consistency, and a well-oiled follow-up process.
Fix It: Streamline your lead follow-up process with automated email sequences or a CRM system that helps your team manage inquiries efficiently. Automating the follow-up can save time, increase accuracy, and ultimately lead to more conversions. With several AI capabilities and automated touch points, there should be 2-3 contacts prior to an appointment, and at least 1-2 follow-ups afterward, with a clear plan.
In fact, it’s been proven that if you want a lead to show up for a meeting, interview, sales call, etc., 5 touch points leading up to that meeting, along with actionable deliverables immediately after, significantly increase sales conversions.
Key Steps to Fix Your Website’s Lead Conversion:
- Improve Navigation: Make it easy for visitors to find what they need, fast.
- Optimize for Speed: A slow site loses leads—keep load times under 3 seconds.
- Ensure Mobile Responsiveness: Your site must work seamlessly on all devices.
- Place Clear CTAs: Guide users to take action with strategic, prominent CTAs.
- Provide Value: Don’t just sell—educate your audience to build trust.
- Streamline Lead Follow-Up: Set up automated follow-up systems to ensure no lead goes cold.
Your website should be working hard to convert visitors into leads—not ghosting them. With the right mix of website design and lead-generation optimization, you can transform your site into a lead-generating machine. Keep your navigation clean, your site fast, your CTAs clear, and always, always offer value, with a plan, and FOLLOW UP!
Remember, think of your website more like an organism than a static object. Optimizing your website is not a one-time fix but is a growing, ongoing process that takes time to perfect. By making these tweaks, you’ll improve user experience, increase conversions, and ultimately, win back the leads.